How To Start A Microgreens Business: Legal And Financial Considerations
Some of our posts on Microgreensguru.com contain affiliate links. If you click on an affiliate link and make a purchase, we may receive a commission. Clicking on an affiliate link that earns a commission does NOT result in additional charges or costs you extra. Earnings from affiliate links help keep this website running. See our full affiliate disclosure here.
Are you considering starting your own microgreens business but feeling overwhelmed by the legal and financial aspects? Don’t worry – you’re not alone. Microgreens have risen in popularity due to their numerous health benefits, ease of growth, and high-profit margins, making them an attractive option for budding entrepreneurs.
In this blog post, we’ll break down the essential steps to turn your microgreens passion into a thriving business venture while navigating the necessary legalities and financial considerations.
Key Takeaways
- Conduct market research to identify target consumers and competitors in the microgreens business.
- Consider the legal requirements for starting a microgreens business, such as obtaining necessary permits and licenses, choosing a suitable legal structure, and complying with food safety regulations.
- Determine startup costs and explore funding options suitable for your circumstances while creating an effective pricing strategy.
- Set yourself up for success by growing quality products sustainably and implementing effective marketing strategies.
Understanding The Market Demand For Microgreens
To start a successful microgreens business, it’s crucial to understand the market demand by identifying target consumers and researching the competition to develop a unique selling proposition.
Identifying Consumers And Their Needs
One of the first steps to starting a successful microgreens business is identifying your target consumers and understanding their specific needs. This involves conducting market research to determine who is most likely to purchase microgreens, such as health-conscious individuals, home chefs passionate about fresh ingredients, or restaurants seeking high-quality local produce for their menus.
For example, if you find that there is significant demand from local grocery stores looking for nutritious food options with a longer shelf life than traditional greens, consider focusing on growing more varieties of microgreens with longer storage capabilities, like kale and spinach.
On the other hand, if upscale restaurants in your area are expressing interest in purchasing unique gourmet items for their dishes, explore cultivating exotic microgreen varieties like amaranth or fennel.
Researching The Competition
Thorough research on the competition is a vital step when planning to launch a successful microgreens business. Analyzing competitors in your local market, as well as online, will provide valuable insights into their strengths and weaknesses while helping you identify potential gaps in the marketplace that your own microgreen venture can fill.
Visiting farmers’ markets or high-end restaurants where microgreens are sold can also offer useful information about target customers and pricing strategies. Take note of which varieties are most popular among consumers and seek out unique selling propositions (USPs) that may differentiate your product offerings.
Additionally, don’t hesitate to engage with other small-scale growers or online forums specializing in microgreens for firsthand accounts of experiences within the industry.
Legal Considerations For Starting A Microgreens Business
When starting a microgreens business, it’s important to consider legal considerations such as obtaining necessary permits and licenses, choosing a business structure, and complying with food safety regulations.
Choosing A Business Structure And Registering Your Business
Deciding on the right business structure for your microgreens venture is a crucial step toward its success. To help guide you through this process, consider the following:
1. Evaluate different business structures: Weigh the pros and cons of various structures, such as sole proprietorships, partnerships, limited liability companies (LLCs), and corporations, to determine which one best fits your needs.
2. Consider liability protection: Some business structures, like LLCs and corporations, offer personal asset protection in case of debts or lawsuits.
3. Tax implications: Research how each business structure may affect your tax responsibilities, including filing requirements and rates.
4. Consult with professionals: Seek advice from an attorney or accountant familiar with local laws and regulations to ensure compliance.
5. Register your business name: Choose a unique name for your microgreens business and register it with the appropriate state agency to protect your brand’s identity.
6. Obtain an EIN (Employer Identification Number): An EIN is required by the IRS for businesses with employees or those operating as a partnership or corporation; however, even if not mandatory, obtaining one can be useful for opening a business bank account or applying for credit.
7. Register for state and local taxes: Depending on your chosen business structure and location, you may need to register for state sales tax or other applicable taxes associated with your microgreens company.
8. Open a separate bank account: To maintain clear financial records and make accounting easier, open a dedicated bank account exclusively for your microgreens operation.
9. Consult local zoning regulations: Before starting operations at home or in another facility, verify that growing microgreens aligns with zoning laws in your area.
By systematically addressing these points while establishing your microgreens venture’s legal framework, you’ll lay the foundation necessary to support its eventual growth and success
Obtaining Necessary Permits And Licenses
Starting a microgreens business requires careful planning and compliance with legal considerations. Here are some steps to follow when obtaining the necessary permits and licenses:
1. Research the specific licenses and permits needed in your area: Depending on your location and type of business, you may need a food permit from local health departments.
2. Complete the necessary paperwork: Once you have identified the required licenses, complete all necessary applications and paperwork accurately. Be sure to provide relevant information, such as your business name, location, and ownership structure.
3. Submit your application: Submit your completed application along with any associated fees to the appropriate government agency or department. Some agencies may require additional documentation or inspections before issuing a permit.
4. Renewals and compliance: It is important to keep track of renewal dates for all licenses and permits that you obtain. Businesses that fail to comply with regulations risk losing permits or facing fines.
Proper registration with the IRS, opening a business bank account, and obtaining a business credit card are also important steps in starting a microgreens business. By following these steps carefully, new microgreen growers can avoid costly mistakes while ensuring compliance with legal requirements.
Complying With Food Safety Regulations
To ensure the safety of your microgreens and comply with food safety regulations, it’s crucial to implement proper growing practices. The Produce Safety Rule outlines requirements for all produce growers, including microgreens, such as using safe water sources, practicing good hygiene during harvesting and packing, and properly labeling products with accurate information about the grower and origin of the produce.
Additionally, seed selection is critical in preventing potential contamination by harmful bacteria like Salmonella or E.coli.
It’s also essential to keep records of your growing practices to demonstrate compliance with regulations — this is particularly important if you plan on selling directly to grocery stores or restaurants that require proof of food safety measures.
Financial Considerations For Starting A Microgreens Business
Determining the startup costs and creating a pricing strategy are critical steps in starting a successful microgreens business, so let’s dive deep into these financial considerations to learn more.
Determining Startup Costs And Funding Options
Starting a microgreens business requires a clear understanding of your startup costs and the various funding options available to you. The following table breaks down the common costs associated with starting a microgreens business and offers potential funding sources to help you get your venture off the ground.
Startup Costs | Description | Estimated Cost |
Seeds and Growing Media | These are essential supplies for cultivating microgreens. You’ll need seeds for your chosen varieties and a growing medium such as soil or coconut coir. | $100 – $500 |
Equipment and Supplies | Necessary equipment includes grow lights, trays, shelving, and irrigation systems. Supplies such as growing containers, packaging, and labels are also needed. | $200 – $1,000 |
Permits and Licenses | Depending on your location, you may need various permits and licenses to operate a microgreens business legally. | $50 – $500 |
Marketing and Promotion | Business cards, website development, and social media promotion are some marketing expenses to consider. | $100 – $500 |
Insurance | Some insurance policies, such as general liability and product liability, may be necessary for your microgreens business. | $300 – $1,000 |
Funding Options | Description | Resource |
Personal Savings | Use your own savings as an initial capital investment to start your microgreens business. | — |
Bank Loans | Apply for a small business loan from a local bank or credit union to help finance your microgreens business. | Your bank or credit union |
Grants | Search for grant opportunities from government agencies or private organizations targeting agricultural businesses or small businesses in general. | Grants.gov |
Crowdfunding | Use crowdfunding platforms to raise funds for your microgreens business from a large group of people. | Kickstarter, Indiegogo |
By thoroughly examining your startup costs and exploring funding options suitable for your circumstances, you can effectively manage your finances and set your microgreens business up for success.
Creating A Pricing Strategy And Profit Margin
Pricing your microgreens correctly is a critical part of starting a successful business. It’s essential to consider all the costs involved in growing and selling your product when deciding on a price.
These costs include everything from seeds and soil to labor, packaging, and overhead expenses such as utilities or rent.
To establish profit margins, you’ll have to subtract total costs from total revenue. For instance, if you sell one tray (approximately 10″ x 20″) of microgreens for $30 but spend $15 on materials like seeds, soil mixtures or mats, containers or trays plus other overheads (including electricity bills), then you make up around $15 per tray sold at full cost.
Some businesses that specialize in providing high-end restaurants with produce may be able to charge significantly higher prices than those looking to sell direct-to-consumer outlets such as grocery stores or farmer’s markets.
Good pricing means avoiding being overpriced – it can lead prospects astray from patronizing; neither should they be too low; this way will eat into profits over time through inadequate returns while struggling with the break-even points yearly due to monthly farm expenses like staff salary and others.
Managing Accounting And Tax Responsibilities
As with any business, managing accounting and tax responsibilities is a critical step in the success of your microgreens business. Keeping track of all expenses and income will help you maintain an accurate profit margin.
To ensure that you’re meeting all necessary requirements, consider hiring an accountant or bookkeeper to manage your finances.
It’s crucial to understand the tax implications associated with running a microgreens business, including sales tax collection and state/federal income taxes.
Sourcing And Growing Microgreens
Learn about the right microgreen varieties to choose, sustainable growing practices, and how to ensure quality control and shelf life in your microgreens business – all essential knowledge for the successful sourcing and growing of microgreens.
Choosing The Right Microgreen Varieties
Popular microgreen varieties like radish, sunflower, and pea shoots are safe bets for a microgreens business. However, it’s important to consider your target market and their preferences before making a decision. Here are some factors to consider when choosing the right microgreen varieties:
1. Taste: Choose varieties that have a mild flavor if you plan on selling to a wider range of customers. On the other hand, if you plan on catering to high-end restaurants, consider offering more robust flavors.
2. Appearance: Microgreens with vibrant colors and interesting shapes are more visually appealing and can attract more customers.
3. Growth time: Some microgreens grow faster than others, so it’s essential to choose varieties that have a consistent growth rate to ensure that there is always supply available.
4. Yield: Certain microgreen varieties offer higher yields than others, which can help maximize profits.
5. Availability: Ensure that the seeds for your chosen varieties are readily available from reputable suppliers.
By considering these factors and researching consumer demand in your area, you can choose the right mix of microgreen varieties for your business.
Sourcing Seeds And Other Materials
To successfully start a microgreens business, it is important to source high-quality seeds and materials. Here are some tips to help you:
1. Research suppliers: Look for reputable suppliers who specialize in providing microgreen seeds and materials. Check reviews and ratings from other growers before making a purchase.
2. Choose the right seed varieties: Selecting the right seeds is critical to the success of your microgreens business. Consider factors such as flavor, texture, color, growth rate, and yield when selecting your seed varieties.
3. Obtain growing equipment: You will need trays, grow lights, potting soil or growing mats, and other equipment to get started. Research and compare prices for these items to ensure that you get good value for your money.
4. Consider organic options: Many customers seek out organic produce and are willing to pay more for it. Consider sourcing organic seeds and materials if this is something that aligns with your values.
5. Maintain inventory levels: Make sure you have enough stock on hand to meet customer demand without overstocking and wasting resources.
Sourcing high-quality seeds and materials is an essential step in launching a successful microgreens business. By following these tips, you can set yourself up for success while minimizing costs and waste.
Implementing Sustainable Growing Practices
Implementing sustainable growing practices in your microgreens business is not only good for the environment, but it can also increase the quality and shelf life of your product.
One way to do this is through composting – using food waste or other organic material to create nutrient-rich soil for your microgreens.
You can also reduce energy usage by using LED lights that consume less power than traditional grow lights. Finally, consider sourcing materials such as seed trays and packaging from sustainable sources to minimize waste and lower your carbon footprint.
Ensuring Quality Control And Shelf Life
Quality control and maintaining the shelf life of microgreens are essential for any successful microgreen business. The delicate nature of these plants requires careful attention to detail throughout the growing process.
To ensure the highest quality product, it is important to implement proper sanitation practices during both pre-harvesting and post-harvesting stages.
In addition, understanding the optimal storage conditions for each type of microgreen is crucial in maintaining its shelf life. Proper packaging and labeling with clear expiration dates can also help customers trust your product’s freshness.
Equipment And Supplies For A Microgreens Business
Identifying necessary equipment and supplies is crucial for a successful microgreens business, including growing trays, lighting, irrigation systems, and quality soil.
Identifying Necessary Equipment And Supplies
To start a successful microgreens business, it’s vital to have the necessary equipment and supplies. Here are some essential items you’ll need:
1. Growing trays or containers: These can be made of plastic or metal and should be shallow with good drainage holes.
2. Seeds: Choose high-quality seeds that are specifically intended for growing microgreens.
3. Growing medium: You can use soil, coconut coir, or other hydroponic growing mediums to grow your microgreens.
4. Lighting: Microgreens need adequate light to grow properly, so you’ll need to invest in proper lighting fixtures such as LED grow lights.
5. Watering supplies: You’ll need a source of clean water and a watering system like a spray bottle or drip irrigation system to keep your microgreens hydrated.
6. Temperature control equipment: Microgreens require consistent temperatures between 60-75°F (15-24°C). You may need fans, heaters, or air conditioning units depending on your location’s climate.
7. Scissors or harvest knife: When your microgreens are ready for harvest, you’ll need scissors or a knife to cut them from the tray.
8. Packaging materials: To sell your microgreens, you’ll need packaging materials like clear clamshell containers and labels with nutritional information and expiration dates.
Having these essential items on hand and maintaining their quality over time will help you grow healthy and thriving microgreens that customers will love!
Sourcing And Purchasing Options
In order to start a successful microgreens business, it’s important to have the right equipment and supplies. Luckily, there are many options available for sourcing and purchasing what you need.
You can find everything from grow lights and trays to seeds and growing mats online or at local gardening stores. Many suppliers offer bulk discounts, making it even more cost-effective to get started.
Additionally, some microgreen farmers opt for environmentally-friendly materials such as reusable trays made of bamboo or recycled plastic in order to reduce waste. By finding sustainable sources for all of your necessary materials, you’ll be able to lower costs over time while simultaneously attracting eco-conscious customers who appreciate ethical business practices.
Optimal Growing Conditions For Microgreens
To grow high-quality microgreens, it’s essential to provide optimal growing conditions. Microgreens require a warm environment with plenty of light and moisture. Ideally, you’ll want to grow them in a room with a temperature between 60-75 degrees Fahrenheit and about 16 hours of light per day.
Choosing the right growing medium is also crucial for successful microgreen farming.
You also need to ensure proper ventilation and humidity levels to prevent mold growth while maintaining adequate air circulation around your plants. Monitoring these conditions regularly will help you avoid potential disasters that can ruin your entire crop before harvest.
Creating A Business Plan For A Microgreens Business
Creating a business plan for your microgreens business involves identifying your target market and unique selling proposition, developing a marketing strategy, and creating a crop plan.
Identifying Your Target Market And Unique Selling Proposition
To make your microgreens business stand out in a competitive market, it is crucial to identify your target market and unique selling proposition. Start by identifying the types of customers who would be interested in purchasing your microgreens, such as local restaurants or high-end grocery stores.
Once you have identified these factors, create a marketing plan that highlights why your microgreens are worth buying. This could include showcasing your growing process or partnering with local chefs to develop recipes featuring your product.
Developing A Marketing Strategy
Creating a marketing strategy for your microgreens business is a critical step in attracting and retaining customers. Start by identifying your target market and unique selling proposition to differentiate yourself from the competition.
Establishing sales channels such as local grocery stores, restaurants, or farmer’s markets can also help you build a customer base and generate consistent demand. It’s important to understand what potential customers are looking for and tailor your promotional messages accordingly.
Creating A Crop Plan
Creating a crop plan is a critical step in starting your microgreens business. It involves deciding which varieties of microgreens to grow, how much to plant, and the timing of planting for optimal yield.
When creating your crop plan, consider factors such as market demand, growing conditions, and shelf life. For example, if there’s high demand for pea shoots in your local market and they’re easy to grow in your space, then it makes sense to include them in your crop plan.
Additionally, it would help if you aimed to stagger planting times so that you have a consistent supply of fresh microgreens throughout the week or month.
Keep in mind that planning is crucial for anyone considering a microgreens business. Your business plan should include all relevant information about your crops’ needs and timelines while also including a financial analysis that will let you know what kind of investment this venture would require upfront before seeing any returns on investment (ROI).
Marketing And Sales Strategies For A Microgreens Business
Establishing sales channels, building a customer base, and promoting your brand through effective marketing materials are critical steps in developing successful marketing and sales strategies for a microgreens business.
Establishing Sales Channels
It’s important to establish sales channels that work best for your microgreens business. Here are some options:
1. Local Farmers Markets: Farmers markets provide an excellent opportunity to sell your microgreens directly to local customers. This is a great way to make connections and build relationships with potential customers.
2. Online Sales: You can create an online store where people can buy your microgreens. This can be a great option, especially if you’re looking to reach customers outside of your local area.
3. Local Grocery Stores and Restaurants: Reach out to local grocery stores and restaurants in your area to see if they would be interested in buying your microgreens. This is a good option for those who want consistent demand for their products.
4. Direct Sales: If you have the resources, consider hiring a sales team that can go door-to-door or make phone calls to potential customers.
5. Specialty Stores: Consider selling your microgreens at specialty stores like health food stores or high-end restaurants. These places may be willing to pay top dollar for quality products.
Remember, whatever sales channel you choose, it’s important to promote your brand through effective marketing materials and building strong customer relationships. And don’t forget, using relevant site titles, meta descriptions, and keywords is crucial when marketing your microgreens business online!
Building A Customer Base
One of the key factors in running a successful microgreens business is establishing a loyal customer base. There are several effective ways to do this, including developing personal connections with local restaurants and grocery stores that may be interested in buying your product.
Another strategy for building a customer base is by attending farmers’ markets or other community events where you can showcase your microgreens directly to the public. This allows potential customers to see and taste your product firsthand, which can increase brand awareness and lead to direct sales.
Promoting Your Brand Through Effective Marketing Materials
Once you have established your microgreens business, it’s time to promote your brand and products through effective marketing materials. Your packaging, labels, and promotional materials should reflect the quality of your product and communicate its unique selling proposition to potential customers.
Consider investing in high-quality branding that speaks directly to your target audience.
Another critical aspect of promoting your brand is establishing a strong online presence. Create a website and social media accounts where potential customers can learn more about your business and place orders directly from you.
Utilize search engine optimization (SEO) tactics to ensure that your website ranks highly on Google searches for terms related to microgreens or local produce.
Research has shown that word-of-mouth recommendations from satisfied customers are one of the most powerful forms of marketing for small businesses like microgreens farms or producers.
Overall, having an effective marketing strategy will play a critical role in growing any successful microgreen business as it helps build relationships between growers/producers/administrators/staff & buyers/retailers/customers leading up to increased sales volumes over time as well as long-term success within competitive markets along with adequate planning required whenever possible- this leads inevitably towards both customer loyalty & higher profits ultimately benefiting everyone involved!
Packaging And Shipping For A Microgreens Business
When it comes to packaging and shipping for a microgreens business, it’s essential to choose appropriate materials that preserve shelf life, comply with labeling regulations, and protect the delicate greens during transit.
Choosing Appropriate Packaging Materials
Choosing the right packaging material is important for a microgreens business as it not only ensures the safe delivery of products to customers but also helps to project an eco-friendly image. Here are some factors to consider when selecting appropriate packaging materials:
1. Sustainability: Packaging materials should be environmentally friendly and biodegradable, such as paper-based bags or boxes made from recycled materials.
2. Size: The packaging should be just the right size to avoid waste and ensure that the microgreens do not move around during transportation.
3. Stickers: Stickers can be used to label the microgreens with important information, such as variety, date of packaging, and expiry date.
4. Cost-effectiveness: Choosing cost-effective packaging options can help manage expenses for a microgreens business while ensuring that quality is maintained.
5. Health risks: It is important to evaluate potential health risks associated with packaging materials before using them for food products.
By considering these factors, a microgreens business can select appropriate packaging materials that are both practical and environmentally friendly while ensuring the safe delivery of goods to customers.
Ensuring Proper Labeling And Compliance
Proper labeling and compliance are essential aspects when it comes to packaging and shipping for a microgreens business. The FDA has specific requirements that must be met, including the name and complete business address of where the microgreens were grown.
Labels on the packaging also provide an opportunity for businesses to share information with consumers about growing practices, nutritional values, or unique selling points. Compliance with regulations related to packaging and labeling can ensure the success of a microgreens business by avoiding costly mistakes or legal issues down the line.
Shipping Considerations And Options
Shipping is a critical aspect of any microgreens business as it determines the quality and freshness of produce upon delivery. Here are some shipping considerations and options to keep in mind:
1. Research Shipping Providers: Look for trusted shipping providers with experience in handling perishable goods. Consider factors such as delivery times, shipping fees, and ability to handle microgreens shipments.
2. Use Proper Packaging: Choose packaging that can keep your microgreens fresh during shipping. Use insulated containers with ice packs or other cooling systems to maintain the right temperature throughout the journey.
3. Labeling and Compliance: Ensure your packaging is labeled correctly per regulations and guidelines for food products. This includes dates, lot numbers, producer’s information, and other relevant information.
4. Know Your Costs: The cost of shipping can vary depending on the size of the shipment, distance traveled, and carrier used. Do research on different carriers’ prices before making a decision.
5. Plan Ahead: Plan your harvests according to anticipated orders so that you can avoid delays in delivery or run-out-of-stock situations that can impact customer satisfaction.
6. Communicate With Customers: Keep customers informed about their order status by sending updates through email or text messages once their orders have been shipped.
7. Local Delivery: Consider delivering directly to local businesses or partnering with local farmer’s markets to avoid shipping costs altogether.
By considering these important shipping considerations and options, you will be able to get your microgreens to market quickly while keeping them fresh and maintaining consistent quality every time.
Scaling And Expansion Of A Microgreens Business
To scale and expand a microgreens business, one can consider increasing production capacity, diversifying product offerings, entering into new markets, hiring staff, and implementing efficient day-to-day operations management.
Expanding Production Capacity
Once you have established your microgreens business, expanding production capacity becomes a critical step for growth. To increase production, you can consider adding more trays to your existing setup or investing in a larger growing space.
However, it is crucial to keep in mind that scaling too quickly without proper planning may lead to costly mistakes. Taking time to develop a growth plan with realistic goals and sufficient resources will ensure successful expansion efforts.
Diversifying Product Offerings
One way to expand your microgreens business is by diversifying your product offerings. While some customers may prefer traditional microgreen varieties like sunflower or pea shoots, others may be interested in trying out more exotic options such as wasabi mustard or purple basil.
Diversifying your product offerings can also help increase business revenue and attract new customers. By experimenting with different seed varietals and mixtures, you can create a product lineup that sets you apart from competitors.
Entering Into New Markets
Expanding into new markets can be a critical step in growing your microgreens business. One way to do this is by identifying potential customers and building personal connections with them.
For example, you could reach out to local high-end restaurants or grocery stores that prioritize locally sourced produce. You could also consider selling your microgreens directly to consumers at farmers’ markets or online through your website.
Keep in mind that entering into new markets may come with additional expenses. You’ll need to adequately assess the startup costs associated with expanding production capacity, sourcing materials and equipment, and marketing efforts tailored toward reaching these new customers.
Hiring Staff And Managing Day-to-day Operations
As your microgreens business grows, you might need to hire staff to help manage the day-to-day operations. This can include positions like harvesters, packagers, and delivery drivers.
When hiring employees, make sure they share your passion for growing microgreens and are reliable and hardworking.
Managing day-to-day operations involves overseeing the entire process, from sourcing seeds to delivering the final product to customers. This includes coordinating with suppliers and distributors, managing inventory levels, maintaining quality control standards, and ensuring that all food safety regulations are met.
To stay organized, consider using customer relationship management (CRM) software or project management tools like Trello or Asana to keep track of tasks and deadlines.
Conclusion: Tips For Success In The Microgreens Business
Starting a microgreens business is an excellent way to earn money while doing something you love. With minimal investment and time, anyone can grow microgreens and turn them into a profitable venture.
Understanding legal and financial considerations is critical for success in the industry.
To succeed in the competitive market of selling microgreens, one should also focus on growing quality products sustainably while implementing effective marketing strategies such as creating promotional materials or establishing sales channels with local businesses or restaurants.
Frequently Asked Questions About Starting a Microgreens Business
Cal Hewitt is the Founder and Lead Cultivator at Microgreens Guru, a website dedicated to empowering individuals to grow, consume, and potentially sell nutrient-dense microgreens. With 5 years of hands-on experience in microgreens cultivation, Cal brings a unique analytical perspective to the world of urban agriculture. He specializes in optimizing growth techniques for various microgreen varieties, while also focusing on sustainable and cost-effective growing methods. Cal’s passion for microgreens, ignited by a personal health journey, drives him to continuously explore and share innovative approaches to microgreens cultivation. His practical experience, combined with his commitment to education through his website and upcoming book, ensures that Microgreens Guru remains a valuable resource for both novice and experienced growers alike.